At least Kevin MacDonald can go into his meeting with Randy Lerner with a smile on his face. Whether MacDonald wants to take over as manager or, perhaps more to the point, whether the Villa owner is interested in appointing him, remains to be seen, but three points here have gone some way towards repairing the damage inflicted after a chastening week that included a 6-0 thumping at Newcastle and elimination from Europe.

Everton were the more accomplished side and laid siege to the Villa goal at times but Luke Young’s splendid early strike, when he curled a left-footed shot beyond Tim Howard, proved the difference. The relief at the final whistle was tangible and not only among the Villa supporters. MacDonald, who has been in charge on a caretaker basis since Martin O’Neill walked out five days before the start of the season, looked emotionally drained.

Lerner made a visit to the home dressing room afterwards to congratulate MacDonald and the players. The Villa chairman will start interviewing for a successor to O’Neill during the international break and he has told MacDonald he will need to know whether he wishes to be considered for the position by tomorrow morning at the latest. The 50-year-old is comfortable with that timetable, although he remains none the wiser about whether to throw his name forward.

“Mr Lerner came in to say well done to the players,” MacDonald said. “He also passed on a comment to say well done to myself and Tony [McAndrew, MacDonald's assistant], because he knows the emotions we had been going through [on the touchline].

“He said: ‘Take your time and enjoy your evening, think about what we have said before and speak to him tomorrow evening or at the latest Tuesday morning.’ But he didn’t put any pressure on me, which I was pleased about.

“I still don’t know whether it’s for me or not. I have thoughts where I want to do it and I’ve had other thoughts that this isn’t what my life is about. I have also got to believe that I am going to be good enough myself. That’s something that I think about deeply. I’ve got to believe that I am good enough to make sure Aston Villa stays where it is and, hopefully, progresses, whether that’s with some more younger players or whatever.”

The Villa caretaker, who was more animated on the touchline than in previous matches, would have been breathing more easily if his side had taken one of the opportunities they spurned on the counterattack. Tim Howard, the Everton goalkeeper, thwarted John Carew and Ashley Young on a couple of occasions but the most inviting chance for Villa to double their lead fell to Marc Albrighton. With Howard stranded, the young winger blazed horribly over from six yards out.

Everton left the pitch crestfallen and well they might. David Moyes’s side played like the home team, taking the game to Villa and doing everything but score. The statistics said it all: Everton controlled 68% of possession and had 18 corners to Villa’s four. It was as much as Villa could do to get out of their half at times and, in the closing stages, they were hanging on for dear life. Deep into injury time, Brad Friedel denied Louis Saha with two fine saves.

Plenty of Everton chances had also come and gone before the frantic finale. Steven Pienaar struck the crossbar in the 18th minute with a brilliant curling shot while Saha, whose arrival for the ineffective Jermaine Beckford gave Everton some much-needed thrust up front, drew a smart reflex save from Friedel on the hour. Three minutes later Jack Rodwell found space in the Villa penalty area but his glancing header from Mikel Arteta’s free-kick flashed inches wide.

All of which was of little consolation to Moyes, who has presided over Everton’s worst start to a league season in 11 years. “If that’s the case, it’s another milestone I’ve achieved,” said Everton’s manager, who admitted his team were guilty of over-elaborating at times. “When you don’t feel as though you are scoring freely, you try and be over-precise. But we did enough to come away with something, if not more than one point.”

Premier LeagueAston VillaEvertonStuart Jamesguardian.co.uk

• Aston Villa players want MacDonald to replace Martin O’Neill
• Former Liverpool man gets decisions spot on in first match

When Kevin MacDonald joined Liverpool in the 1980s, his constant moaning earned him the nickname Albert Tatlock after the grumpy old man played by Jack Howarth in Coronation Street. Something has obviously changed since he hung up his boots because his presence in the Aston Villa dugout on Saturday put smiles on faces and liberated a group of players who would like nothing better than to see him named as their new manager.

Stiliyan Petrov, the Villa captain, led the calls for MacDonald to be appointed Martin O’Neill’s successor after an exhilarating performance that had the chairman, Randy Lerner, on his feet and the supporters chanting the caretaker’s name. It was that sort of day at Villa Park and if the players get their way it will be the first of many under MacDonald. “We couldn’t have a better man to step in and take charge,” said Petrov, who scored Villa’s second goal with a superb header.

“I said to him before, you try and hold on to that job. He has been at the club a long time and has done a great job with the youth. He showed with how he prepared us, and the way he wants us to play, that he wants to hold on to the job. I hope we can help him to take it. We are behind him. He knows it’s hard for him; expectations are high and people want success and talk about big names. But he is really determined to stay there.”

Lerner is now treating him as a serious contender and it is easy to see why. MacDonald’s approach to the job has been impressive ever since he stepped up from reserve-team duties last Monday. He introduced changes to training by working closely with the side that would start against West Ham, rather than keeping everyone waiting until the day of the game to find out who was playing (as was the case under O’Neill) and he got his team selection spot on.

Pundits said it was impossible to play James Milner because of the distraction of his proposed transfer to Manchester City but MacDonald’s faith in the midfielder was vindicated and his decision to include a couple of academy graduates, Ciaran Clark and Marc Albrighton, brought instant reward. But perhaps the most impressive aspect of Saturday’s display was the tactical change that allowed Villa to play as if the shackles had come off.

“Every manager has a different style and Kev has a different vision on how we can play, and we showed we can be faster and play with more freedom,” Petrov said. “We are moving the ball quicker. We try to hurt teams, not just play on the counterattack, and we created a lot of chances. It could have been a different result, not just 3-0. He gives us a new way to play, more freedom, and when you know exactly what you need to do, it makes it easier to perform.”

Nobody performed better than Albrighton. A regular under MacDonald in the reserves, the 20-year-old winger was outstanding on his full Premier League debut as he tormented West Ham with his sinuous runs and dexterous footwork on both flanks. He set up the first goal for Stewart Downing and brilliantly created the third for Milner, who left the field to a standing ovation with five minutes to goand with his name reverberating around the stadium.

“I really enjoyed every minute of it,” said Albrighton, who grew up supporting Villa and lives only a few miles from the training ground. “Kevin said go out there and enjoy it, and play the way I have the last few years. I have done it for one game of the season and have to keep my feet on the ground. As soon as I came off the pitch, James Milner said: ‘You have set a standard there, you have to keep that going for 37 games.’ He is bang on.”

West Ham will be relegated if they show the same form over the remainder of the season. Julien Faubert should have pulled a goal back after the restart but that was a rare West Ham attack on an afternoon when only John Carew’s profligacy and the woodwork spared Avram Grant’s side a hammering. “If we are not fighting against relegation, which I believe will be the case, we can develop our game and improve our football,” the West Ham manager said rather unconvincingly.

Man of the match Marc Albrighton (Aston Villa) Little wonder he stayed in to watch Match of the Day on Saturday night.

Premier LeagueAston VillaWest Ham UnitedStuart Jamesguardian.co.uk